Monday, July 12, 2010

Feel the Burn

Last month PricewaterhouseCoopers released its predictions for Medical cost trends in 2011. The target audience for this report is employers, but it is very enlightening for everybody else. Unsurprisingly health care costs for 2011 are projected at a whopping $3 trillion, but the good news is that the growth in medical costs is projected to be only 9%, down half a percentage point. The good news is of course for employers since these are projections for employers’ costs. How about the rest of us? Will the news trickle down to employees? They sure will, but not exactly as you may think.

PwC distills the complexity down to three factors pushing costs down (deflators) and three factors pushing costs up (inflators) as follows (keep in mind that these are employer costs):

Deflators
  • Move to benefits designed to offload cost to employees in the form of higher deductibles, co-insurance and higher co-pays.
  • Increased utilization of generics
  • Reductions in COBRA benefits due to better economy and expiration of government subsidies
Inflators
  • Cost shifting to private insurers due to Medicare payment cuts to hospitals
  • Consolidation of private practices from a “cottage industry” to large groups with significant bargaining power
  • HIT Meaningful Use expenditures passed on to payers
If we look at the “deflators”, other than generics utilization and the commendable faith in the US economy, coupled with complete disregard for the unemployed rabble, it seems that one’s deflator is another’s inflator. Consumers will be spending a lot more on this intricate web of deductibles, co-pays (flat fees) and co-insurance (a percentage of costs). That is good for us. We will finally develop sensitivity to the real costs of health care as we become empowered to manage our own health, or lack thereof. To meet this need, there will be a vast array of iPhone applications to guide us away from what we need and towards what best deflates our employer’s costs. Make no mistake though; employers by definition have the best interests of their employees at heart. Healthy, happy well-adjusted employees are good for the bottom line, just like happy cows make good cheese in California. This is why our employers will help us with these new responsibilities and hire all sorts of wellness management firms to keep us healthy. Firms like Optum Health who has this lovely maintenance center they install at your workplace where you step in and all your wellness parameters get measured and reported. You can be sure now that someone is always watching over you. May not be that guardian angel grandma was talking about, but there’s definitely someone there.

With the exception of the perennial complaint of Medicare cost shifting, the “inflators” deserve our undivided attention, particularly since the net effects will be trickling down uninhibited directly to our cost-offloading, patient-driven “benefits”. Flying in the face of most luminaries’ published opinions, PwC projects that the anticipated demise of Dr. Marcus Welby will fail to deliver the much touted “economies of scale”, and instead will just drive health care costs up. Absolutely shocking! Since this particular report targets business leaders, it is silent on the effects of health care Walmartization on actual quality of care. Let your imagination roam freely here…..

The most surprising “inflator” is the cost of HIT adoption and Meaningful Use of EHRs, which PwC is expecting to be passed on from providers to payers. Not only that HIT is supposed to increase a provider’s efficiency and reduce costs of health care delivery, but I was under the impression that taxpayers already footed that bill to the tune of 20 or 30 billion dollars (who’s counting). Turns out that this was just a down payment and the monthly invoices are in the mail, attached to our brand spanking new premiums.  Yes, I know, it will take several years to see the benefits. The premiums at Kaiser, which started its epic HIT journey in 2003, are not showing any signs of relief. So we wait…..

Here is the beauty of our health insurance system in its true magnificent simplicity:  Both “deflators” and “inflators” are driving prices of health insurance up for working folks. And this, we are told, is very good for us. Well, we all know exercise is good for you, and at least one part of every American is about to get a vigorous workout – the wallet. Can you feel the burn?

Monday, July 5, 2010

Leapfrogging CPOE

Last week, yet another alarming Computerized Physician Order Entry (CPOE) study made headlines. According to Healthcare IT News, The Leapfrog Group, a staunch advocate of CPOE, is now “sounding the alarm on untested CPOE” as their new study “points to jeopardy to patients when using health IT”. Up until now we had inconclusive studies pointing to increased and also decreased mortality in one hospital or another following CPOE implementation, but never an alarm from a non-profit group who made it its business to improve quality in hospitals by encouraging CPOE adoption, and this time the study involved 214 hospitals using a special CPOE evaluation tool over a period of a year and a half.

According to the brief Leapfrog report, 52% of medication errors and 32.8% of potentially fatal errors in adult hospitals did not receive appropriate warnings (42.1% and 33.9% accordingly, for pediatrics). A similar study published in the April edition of Health Affairs (subscription required), using the same Leapfrog CPOE evaluation tool, but only 62 hospitals, provides some more insights into the results. The hospitals in this study are using 7 commercial vendors and one home grown system (not identified), and most interestingly, the CPOE vendor had very little to do with the system’s ability to provide appropriate warnings. For basic adverse events, such as drug-to-drug or drug-to-allergy, an average of 61% of events across all systems generated appropriate warnings. For more complex events, such as drug-to-diagnosis or dosing, appropriate alerts were generated less that 25% of the time. The results varied significantly amongst hospitals, including hospitals using the same product. To understand the implications of these studies we must first understand the Leapfrog CPOE evaluation tool, or “flight simulator” as it is sometimes referred to.

The CPOE “simulator” administers a 6 hours test. It is a web based tool where hospitals can print out a list of 10-12 test patients with pertinent profiles, i.e. age, gender, problem list, meds and allergy list and possibly test results. The hospital needs to enter these patients into their own EHR system. According to Leapfrog, this is best done by admission folks, lab and radiology resources and maybe a pharmacist. Once the test patients are in the EHR, the hospital should log back into the “simulator” and print out about 50 medication orders for those test patients, along with instructions and a paper form for recording CPOE alerts. Once the paper artifacts are created, the hospital is supposed to enter all medication orders into the EHR and record any warnings generated by the EHR on the paper form provided by the “simulator”. This step is best done by a physician with experience in ordering meds in the EHR, but Leapfrog also suggests that the CMIO would be a good choice for entering orders. Finally, the recorded warnings are reentered into the Leapfrog web interface and the tool calculates and displays the hospital scores.

If the process above sounds familiar, it is probably because this is very similar to how CCHIT certifies clinical decision support in electronic prescribing. Preset test patients followed by application of test scripts are intended to verify, or in this case assess, which modules of medication decision support are activated and how the severity levels for each are configured. As Leapfrog’s disclaimer correctly states, this tool only tests the implementation, or configuration, of the system. This is a far cry from a flight simulator where pilot (physician) response is measured against simulated real life circumstances (busy ED, rounding, discharge). The only alarm the Leapfrog study is sounding, and it is an important alarm, is that most hospitals need to turn on more clinical decision support functionality.

It is not clear whether doctors will actually heed decision support warnings, or just ignore them. Since the medication orders are scripted, we have no way of knowing if, hampered by the user interface, docs without a script would end up ordering the wrong meds. And since the “simulator” is really not a simulator, we have no way of knowing if an unfriendly user interface caused the physician to enter the wrong frequency, or dose, or even the wrong medication (Leapfrog has no actual access to the EHR). We have no indication that the system actually recorded the orders as entered, subsequently displayed a correct medication list or transmitted the correct orders to the pharmacy. We cannot be certain that a decision support module which generates appropriate alerts for the test scripts, such as duplicate therapy, will not generate dozens of superfluous alerts in other cases. We do know that alerts are overridden in up to 96% of cases, so more is not necessarily better.
Do the high scoring hospitals have a higher rate of preventing errors, or do they just have more docs mindlessly dismissing more alerts?

All in all, the Leapfrog CPOE evaluation tool is a pretty blunt instrument. However, the notion of a flight simulator for EHRs is a good one. A software package that allows users to simulate response to lifelike presentations, and scores the interaction from beginning to end, accounting for both software performance and user proficiency, would facilitate a huge Leap forward in the quality of HIT. This would be an awesome example of true innovation.

Wednesday, June 30, 2010

Consenting Technologies

Yesterday, ONC held a fine gathering at the Grand Hyatt in Washington DC. There were experts, ONC Tiger team members and cutting edge technology vendors displaying and discussing platforms and software for providing patients the opportunity to define granular consent to the sharing of their electronic medical records down to a data element level. Somewhere in the midst of watching that fabulous and very complex technology, it occurred to me that I don’t quite understand why we are discussing all these things. Obviously, we all agree that patients have a right to privacy, and as HIPAA outlines, our medical records ought to be protected from wanton disclosure without our permission. However, the showcased products and the ensuing conversations at the Grand Hyatt were on a completely different level of sophistication.

Physicians have been exchanging patient records since medical records were invented. Today, patients are signing the obligatory HIPAA forms giving health care providers permission for these exchanges, and most doctors use fax, phone, courier (usually the patient) and occasionally secure email to exchange medical records. A typical scenario would be a PCP making a referral – a letter summarizing the problem is usually written, some test results could be attached, a big yellow envelope with some film may be handed to the patient to bring to their specialist appointment. Physicians equipped with EHRs are doing pretty much the same, in a more automated fashion. We do not consider this an invasion of privacy.

It seems that things are about to change. Data, as we all know, yearns to be free, and once computerized, all data will finally become free (literally and figuratively). Instead of having the doctor select the pertinent information to be released based on circumstances and need to know, all our medical data will be available for access by all interested parties. So in our referral example, the specialist would request, or be granted, access to our entire electronic medical record. For most folks, this would be unacceptable. This is where consent comes in.

Newly empowered patients, or consumers, will need to go through their medical records and choose who can see what and under which circumstances they can see it. First we need to locate our medical records, which could be scattered amongst the various providers we see, or according to the best Toyota principles, will be all aggregated in a PHR that we control. So either we log into various Patient Portals, at various institutions, to give our informed consents, or log into our PHR which magically contains our entire medical record. In the latter case, it is not clear what the exact purpose of the consent would be since each provider would retain their own “unconsented” copy of the records.

Assuming I have a computer, and assuming I have access to the internet, and assuming my English is pretty good, and assuming my health care literacy is decent and I don’t have a disability preventing me from working with a computer, and ignoring these minute details, which are surely going to be resolved soon, let’s proceed with consenting. Since we have a specialist appointment coming up, we should decide what the specialist should see. Probably only stuff associated with the reason we’re going to see her for. We can safely check everything else off. Our PCP ordered an MRI, but we would really like the specialist to do her own tests, so let’s check off the MRI too. On second thought the blood tests looked a bit peculiar the first time around, let’s have some new ones, or let’s see what the specialist decides to order on her own. Checked off.

Now we need some general consent policies too. Who should be able to see our genetic information regarding increased risk for breast cancer? Nobody, that’s our own private business and if the insurers find out, we’re toast. Checked off. How about that little episode of depression? Oh, no, that’s nobody’s business either and we’re fine now. Checked off. At this point, all an unauthorized person can see is that we blocked all access to genetic information regarding breast cancer and mental health information. Hopefully it works better than invoking the Fifth Amendment in a court of law.

I understand Electronic Medical Records and wholeheartedly support their adoption. I understand that physicians need to exchange medical data in order to provide care. I understand per incident data exchange and I understand NHIN Direct. I completely understand a patient’s right to obtain a copy of all his/her records and I definitely understand the imperative to protect medical data from profiteering, legal or otherwise.
However, I do not understand the logic of opening up access to the entire medical record just so that patients can go back in and block same access, data element by data element. I also don’t understand the clinical value of a medical record that can be redacted at will without physician knowledge. And most of all, I don’t understand how small rural and underserved clinics, and their equally underserved patients, get to participate in this exquisite technology plan. Will this exercise improve quality of care? Will it reduce costs? Will it reduce disparities?

Monday, June 28, 2010

RECs – Considerations for EHR RFPs

Section 3012 of the HITECH act establishes Health Information Technology Regional Extension Centers (REC) that will offer technical assistance, guidance and information on best practices to support and accelerate health care providers’ efforts to become meaningful users of Electronic Health Records (EHRs).  Each REC shall aim to provide assistance and education to all providers in a region, but shall prioritize any direct assistance first to the following:
  • Public or not-for-profit hospitals or critical access hospitals.
  • Federally qualified health centers (as defined in section 1861(aa)(4) of the Social Security Act).
  • Entities that are located in rural and other areas that serve uninsured, underinsured, and medically underserved individuals (regardless of whether such area is urban or rural).
  • Individual or small group practices (or a consortium thereof) that are primarily focused on primary care.
So far, ONC has granted over half a billion dollars to 60 RECs to accomplish these goals. One of the first steps the RECs need to take is the evaluation and subsequent recommendation of EHR technologies to their constituents.  Whether the REC selects one EHR to work with, or a short list of preferred vendors, or just a general rating system for multiple vendors, chances are an RFP, or at the very least an RFI, will be issued to EHR vendors.

Following the grant announcement several RECs issued (Requests for Proposals) RFPs and some completed the EHR selection process, while most are still in the process of creating RFPs. The few RFPs currently published are by and large based on the DOQ-IT EHR RFP.  While the DOQ-IT document is excellent for an individual practice, it needs some important adjustments in order to serve a REC’s objectives and stated priorities.
  1. Facilitate EHR adoption for several hundreds, to several thousands of providers, in a short amount of time – This objective will require that for an EHR vendor to be considered, it must have the capacity to actually perform such large scale implementations, both in human resources (quantity and quality) and technical infrastructure scalability. The RFP should inquire about both aspects.
  2. All REC providers must be eligible for Meaningful Use incentives – Any EHR selected by the REC must be, or readily become, ONC certified for Meaningful Use. Since there are currently no ONC approved certifying authorities, the closest an EHR can come to satisfying this requirement is by already being CCHIT 2011 certified (comprehensive or Stage 1).
  3. The first priority for RECs is small Primary Care practices with less than 10 providers – There are two concerns here. First, these practices are usually not cash rich, therefore the EHR licensing model, and any additional fees, needs to be thoroughly explored. Second, there are specific features that are more important for Primary Care and not always available:
      a. Full ACOG documentation capabilities and extensive prenatal education materials for OB
      b. Comprehensive Pediatrics module including immunizations schedules for children with special needs and catch-up schedules
  4. The initial REC effort will be directed at providers serving large Medicaid populations, rural areas and other medically underserved patients. Physicians and clinics providing services in these areas have very specific needs, not necessarily found in most EHRs.
      a. Behavioral Health – Any EHR used for underserved populations must include extensive behavioral health modules or functionality.
      b. Comorbidities – The EHR must allow documentation and treatment of multiple problems in one visit, i.e. loading of multiple templates simultaneously and longitudinal tracking of multiple problems, including patient specific care plans and disease management alerts.
      c. Outreach & Patient Education – In addition to the minimum requirements of MU, underserved populations would be well served by sophisticated outreach tools and extensive, culturally adequate, patient education materials. Specific materials for people with disabilities are also desirable. Just having a PHR is probably not sufficient in areas where there are few computers and health literacy is low.
      d. FQHC functionality – Any EHR used in these settings must have all the regulatory reporting (UDS) and billing capabilities to support federally qualified clinics.
      e. Substance Abuse, Smoking and Obesity – It would be beneficial if the EHR would include content and tools to facilitate counseling along with ability to manage group sessions.
      f. Home Care – Any functionality that allows integration of home care activities into a practice EHR would be beneficial.
      g. Medical Home – Functionality built to better support medical homes creation and operations, such as general care coordination and collaboration, reporting and referral management should be helpful. RECs should inquire if EHR vendor has experience with any PCMH deployment.
      h. Rural Health Connectivity – Considering that most REC implementations will occur in rural settings where broadband and Internet connectivity are not yet as reliable as in urban areas, EHRs should provide contingency plans for ISP outages or lengthy periods of impaired response time.
      i. Patient Volume – Most clinics to be served by RECs have very large and complex patient volumes. EHR ease of use and usability features will be extremely important for successful adoption. Other than testing and evaluating recommended products, RECs should also obtain knowledge of a vendor’s Quality Assurance process and the number of Usability professionals directly involved in product development.
      j. Last, but not least, any EHR vendor selected by a REC should be willing and able to integrate with existing State specific technology efforts to support underserved populations. A good example will be the Indian Health Services RPMS and its Patient Care Component, or any other Medicaid sponsored networks such as MO HealthNet in Missouri.
  5. RECs will be engaging in the largest long term EHR implementation effort to date.  It is to be expected that despite best effort some implementations will fail and some practices will be de-installing EHRs. A detailed plan of action for extracting EHR and PMS data from recommended EHR systems is imperative. RECs should inquire about, and contractually request, equitable data extraction processes.

Note 1: Regarding EHR Modules - Although ONC will be certifying EHR Modules, it will be prudent for RECs tol only accept RFP responses from complete products or vendors aggregating modules into complete products. It would not be advisable for RECs to engage in EHR Module aggregation due to the aggressive timelines and shortage of expertise.

Note 2: Regarding Meaningful Use – At the time of this writing CMS has not finalized the minimum requirements for Stage 1 Meaningful Use. It is very likely that the currently proposed requirements will be reduced in scope. However, the 25 certification requirements for EHRs should remain unchanged. Guaranties notwithstanding, EHRs that fall short of those requirements today are less likely to be able to come up to speed and certify in time for the RECs to meet their aggressive schedules. RECs deciding to recommend such EHR products should, at the very least, identify and clearly explain the risk to their providers.

Wednesday, June 23, 2010

Physicians Right to Privacy

As we move to Electronic Health Records (EHR), the debates over security and privacy are becoming more frequent and more poignant. We of course have HIPAA laws on the books and ONC has a Tiger team assembled to recommend privacy and security policies to Secretary Sebelius. CIOs and entire IT departments are all focused on protecting the privacy of patients and their Personal Health Information (PHI). This is, of course, as it should be, but how about privacy of those taking care of patients? Do physicians have a right to privacy too?

As EHRs become more prevalent and interconnected, increasing amounts of clinical and administrative data will be flowing out of doctors’ offices and into the great beyond. Most of this data is indeed patient data, but some of it could be combined, sliced and diced to derive pretty extensive information about doctors. For example, and in no particular order:

  1. Prescribing patterns – Prescription data has been collected and sold to pharmaceutical companies for decades. EHRs will make this much easier to accomplish and the data will become richer and more granular, since it will contain the exact nature of the visit where a particular drug was prescribed or discontinued, including physician notes on the subject. Of course, such information finding its way to public websites would present a novel difficulty if, say, we can look up Dr. X and see that she wrote 30 prescriptions for contraceptives last month, half of which were for girls under 16 years of age.
  2. In the interest of informing patients on physicians’ expertise, a company may decide to publish names and frequencies of procedures performed by physicians. In addition to the fact that the raw number of performed procedures is not indicative of proficiency if not accompanied by outcomes data which is almost impossible to obtain, our beleaguered Dr. X may find a web listing of the number of abortions she performed on teenage girls right next to her name and home address.
  3. Administrative data can provide average times spent with patients, with no differentiation between the 5 minutes required for allergy meds renewal and the half hour you spent with elderly complex patients. Schedule data can also be manipulated to deduce when you take vacations. Is anybody watching your house while you’re enjoying those exquisite Hawaiian sunsets?
  4. Of course the call for greater transparency will create numerous websites trying to provide patients with a Consumer Reports style rating of doctors. Quality measures similar, or identical, to the ones submitted to CMS will come in very handy. If you report that only 20% of your patients have an acceptable Hb1Ac level and I am a diabetic looking for a good doctor, I’d probably pick one with better “outcomes”. The fact that most of your patients are underserved, poor and even homeless and you are pretty much a saint is not evident in your outcomes. Sorry.
  5. EHR progress note data can indicate how thorough you are. If you routinely document only a handful of Exam and Histories elements, maybe I should find a doctor that takes more time and is more thorough, or one who has an EHR that documents all negatives by exception, whether he looked at it or not. There will be very few patients savvy enough to know the difference.
  6. Here is a more interesting possibility. By examining your SOAP notes, computers can figure out your decision making patterns. These patterns can be cross aggregated and will make for very interesting research. However, these patterns, once established, could also become admissible evidence in a court of law.
As data becomes richer and more liquid, more possibilities to monetize physician data will emerge, just like monetization of patient data will become rampant. Fortunately, patient privacy is central to all new standards and policies being created by the Government. By contrast, physician privacy is not even an afterthought. While physicians have always been morally and legally obligated to protect their patients’ privacy, perhaps the time has come to also consider the doctor’s privacy in this brave new digital world.

Monday, June 21, 2010

Deobfuscating HITECH

Software developers sometimes use a technique called obfuscation to protect their intellectual property. They use tools to add, remove and displace the original flow of the code until no human can understand what it does or how it does anything. Judging by the ample confusion expressed by large numbers of physicians, it almost looks like a giant obfuscator has been applied to the HITECH act leaving the medical community to wonder what to do, why do it and how to proceed. The prevailing wisdom is that, for some misguided reason, the Government is paying for EHRs, but there are so many strings attached that it is very unlikely anybody will ever see a dime of the much advertised $44,000.

First we should figure out what these EHRs can do, or more accurately, will one day be able to do.
  1. Store all your paper records electronically in a computer and make them accessible to many other providers of care, including patients. EHRs, if allowed, can also make all your records available to insurers, Government and any other agencies or corporations who manage to obtain access. There will of course be laws and regulations, consents and all sorts of policies in place to prevent or punish unauthorized access. Electronic data is much more liquid than paper based data, leading to better collaboration, better visibility and like all liquids, has better chances of leakage.
  2. EHRs can slice and dice your data and present you with flowsheets for an individual patient and many reports across your entire panel of patients. You could see how your patients are doing, which ones need to be reminded to come in, or schedule screening tests. It’s hard to do that on paper.
  3. Just like your data is available to others, theirs is available to you. You can see medication lists, specialist notes or PCP histories, hospital records, test results and even home monitoring devices input in real time. Coordination of care should become less time consuming.
  4. EHRs can help you directly communicate with patients (and other doctors) via secure email or even secure teleconference. It can automate making appointments, paying bills, obtaining pre-authorizations and even the entire check-in/check-out process.
  5. EHRs can provide you the latest guidelines and evidence, in a patient specific context. Perhaps even CMEs. Computers are supposedly better at calculations and cross checking large amounts of data, hence they could alert you when an error is about to occur or present you with the latest checklists.
No, all these things are not there now. Some of the simplest ones are, and the rest should become reality after enough physicians start using EHRs and enough EHRs get interconnected to form a critical mass necessary for progress.

OK, so where is the catch? Truth being said, there is more than one catch.
  1. You have to feed the beast. Computers cannot deliver any of the wonderful, or less wonderful, things above, unless somebody enters data into the EHR to start with. While most data can be entered by staff, large portions will have to be collected by the physician.
  2. Computers are intrusive. The EHR will make its presence felt in the exam room. It will alter your interaction with your patients. There are tips and tricks to minimize the change, but it cannot be eliminated altogether.
  3. EHRs are not a finished product. When you “adopt” one, you become part of a learning effort on how to computerize medical records. EHRs have “glitches”. The Internet and broadband have “glitches”. Computers in general have “glitches”. People have many “glitches” too. Nobody invented the perfect method for documenting encounters, for viewing longitudinal records, for ordering tests and most important, EHRs are not yet able to communicate with one another on a large scale.
  4. The Government will have easy access to your records. Your performance may be judged (perhaps inappropriately) and reimbursement may be affected. Patients (and their attorneys) will have unfettered access to your records. Mistakes will be found. Little notes you made just for yourself in the paper chart, are not just for yourself anymore.
  5. EHRs can be expensive. They don’t have to be, but they can be. Picking the wrong piece of software, not getting proper training, not managing the implementation process correctly and failing to continuously manage change may cost you a small fortune, mainly in lost productivity. There are no “lemon laws” for EHRs.
My first cell phone weighed over a pound and had huge buttons and a very ugly antenna. My second cell phone was a flip phone and my third one was Java enabled. I now have an iPhone. My first computer was a main frame IBM 370. I was madly in love with the power of that machine. My second computer was an IBM PC. I named him and took him with me on a long vacation overseas and back. I now have a thin and much more powerful Sony Vaio. I could have sat this whole thing out waiting for the iPhone and the Vaio to be perfect, which they still are not, but I would have been left behind I think. I would have certainly avoided the embarrassment of dragging a 30 lb computer through several airports and the excruciating wait for the modem to connect, or the inconvenience of dropped calls every time I drove by an electricity pole. But I would have also missed the ability to help a Hospital keep receiving lab reports on a Friday night and the opportunity to walk a technician through an entire database restoration from a mountain lodge in the middle of nowhere.

If I were a physician in a small private practice today, I would do my research and locate the cheapest EHR that can do what needs to be done relatively well. I would “adopt” the contraption, regardless of the promised $44,000, probably name it Lucifer and keep an eye on it to make sure it behaves itself. And I would try my hardest to become part of the future and part of the solution, because folks, whether we like it or not, paper is over.

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Kingmaker RECs

ONC has granted many millions of dollars to Regional Extension Centers (RECs) to promote widespread adoption of EHRs, particularly amongst small private practices of primary care physicians. The RECs are chartered to educate and assist physicians and safety net providers with selection and purchase of EHR technology. Much like the Department of Agriculture stepped in to aid farming at the turn of the previous century, the RECs are creations of the HITECH act and the goals are not much different – diffuse Government best practices to small businesses (the controversial aspect of such activities is best discussed separately). It is possible that after the EHR push is completed, RECs will evolve into helping physicians practice better medicine as Atul Gawande envisioned. But right now, RECs are in the process of defining the ambulatory EHR market.

The common knowledge is that the ambulatory EHR market consists of “hundreds” of competing software products and services. Well, there may very well be hundreds of products out there, with hundreds of flashy websites, but very few have a sizable customer base, whith a dozen or so vendors servicing most current EHR customers. HITECH has brought us an influx of new entrants and I am certain there are many more to come between now and 2011. At the same time, market consolidation through mergers and acquisitions is reducing the number of both vendors and products. Just like the Misys/Allscripts merger displaced old Misys products, the Allscripts/Eclipsys merger will definitely retire duplicate or unprofitable products. And there will be more, and probably larger M&As in this space. There will also be the inevitable demises.

So what should a REC do when it comes to helping physicians select an EHR? Should they present several hundred EHRs to the doctor to look at? Perhaps they should limit themselves to the one hundred or so CCHIT certified EHRs? Or better yet send the physician out there to sort through the multitude with a set of instructions on best practices for selection. Chances are the doctor will not even begin to look, let alone actually select something. It therefore falls to the REC to prescreen vendors, at least to a certain degree. RECs are also directed by ONC to form Group Purchasing Organizations (GPOs) and obtain the best possible pricing arrangements for their constituents. Such arrangements are only possible if large numbers of physicians are all buying the same EHR, thus further narrowing the playing field.

Just getting EHRs in physicians’ offices is not nearly enough. RECs are also supposed to facilitate connectivity of their physicians to HIEs and there is ample collaboration between state HIEs and RECs, with some being managed by the same organization. It would be a nightmarish proposition for HIEs and RECs to facilitate connectivity of hundreds of different EHR products. Just like Hospitals before them, RECs and HIEs are likely to select a few EHRs and work on connecting with those first. In an era of universal standards this would not be a problem, but our standards are evolving in parallel with EHR adoption and we have to start somewhere.

The first announcement of short EHR lists came from the two New York State RECs and created much angst in the small vendor community. New York narrowed it down to the usual suspects – mostly large well established EHR vendors. Are New York RECs short sighted? Do they not wish to support innovation and small new products that may turn out to be “the next big thing”? Are they receiving kickbacks from the financially stable vendors? Most likely, none of the above. The RECs must discharge their duties in the here and now. They cannot afford to bet money (taxpayer money) on the “next big thing” and considering that the grants, as generous as they may seem, barely cover the costs of operations, the RECs must mitigate risk. Contracting with a vendor that has “been there, done that”, a vendor that may not have the newest and shiniest technology, but has a boatload of fairly satisfied customers (and unhappy ones too), a vendor commanding an army of trainers and implementers, a vendor that is already connected to many large Hospitals in the State and a vendor with a balance sheet extending well into the past not just into a projected future, is arguably the safest course of action a responsible REC can take.

I would add one more piece of advice to all RECs creating short lists and GPOs. Make sure all your vendors guarantee the ability to extract all data from their current systems. Technology is not standing still and sooner or later game changing software will make its appearance. It may very well be from one of your established vendors, but if it’s not, you have a fiduciary responsibility to your physicians to ensure they can move on to bigger (or smaller) and better things.